Canadians Are Buying Canadian — The GCBI Says Being Canadian Was Never What Made a Brand Trusted
-
Author: Eugene Chan
Published: 18 October 2026 on LinkedInThe Great Canadian Brand Ledger is built on the Great Canadian Brand Index (GCBI), a nationally representative survey of Canadian adults (3,441 respondents in 2026, weighted to 2021 Census benchmarks across age, gender, race, and political affiliation) that measures how Canadians perceive over 130 major brands across seven behavioural trust dimensions: Friendliness, Niceness, Respectfulness, Honesty, Tolerance, Adventurousness, and Sustainability. Brand-level scores are generated using Bayesian shrinkage estimation for stability and reliability, producing each brand's overall GCBI score alongside its individual dimension scores. Where the GCBI provides the annual scores and rankings, the Ledger interprets what's actually moving underneath them, turning value-level shifts into insight about institutional trust, alignment, and drift.
Nineteen months into the trade war, the Buy Canadian movement has not faded. Abacus Data, reporting in early October, re-asked the same questions it first put to Canadians in February 2025. Seventy-seven percent say they intend to avoid American products, essentially unchanged from 78% then. Sixty-one percent say they have bought more Canadian goods, up from 53%. The share with no plans to travel to the United States jumped from 32% to 52%. And in the same survey, 61% say buying Canadian costs more.
That last number matters to everything below. Ipsos, polling a year ago, found that 82% of Canadians said they would keep prioritizing Canadian products after the trade war ends, and that 53% would stop buying from a company that exaggerates how Canadian its products are. Put those together and you have a movement with deep reach, a price tag, and a built-in honesty test. This week's Ledger asks what the GCBI can say about that, and the answer is more interesting than "Canadian brands are trusted."
The first thing to say is what the GCBI cannot do. It tracks only brands that meet a Canadian-origin standard, so there is no American or foreign comparison group in the data. I cannot tell you whether Canadians trust Canadian brands more than foreign ones. That is the movement's central premise, and this index cannot test it. What the index can do is something the movement rarely asks. Hold nationality constant, so that every brand in the dataset is Canadian, and see what still separates the trusted from the distrusted. The polling figures I quote come from published coverage of Abacus and Ipsos surveys, not data I have independently reviewed, and I treat them as directionally informative.
-
Same Flag, 10 points Apart
The 2026 GCBI score range among the 130 brands runs from 69.01 for Chapman's Ice Cream to 58.31 for Loblaws, a gap of 10.7 points. Every brand on that list is Canadian. The top five are Chapman's, Indigo, Cirque du Soleil, Roots, and Canadian Tire. The bottom five, from the bottom up, are Loblaws, Rogers, Bell, Air Canada, and Flair Airlines.
Read the bottom of that list as a Buy Canadian shopper would. Loblaws has been last in the index two years running. Rogers and Bell sit at #129 and #128. Air Canada is #127. These are not obscure foreign entrants slipping into the Canadian market. They are some of the largest, most nationally embedded Canadian-owned companies in the country, and Canadians rate them lowest of everything we measure.
Names do not fix it either. The three brands that sound most like the country itself, Air Canada, Canada Post, and Petro-Canada, rank #127, #117, and #122 out of 130, all in the bottom fourteen. Others that carry the word do well: Canadian Tire is #5, Canada Dry is #13. The word "Canada" in a brand's name tells you almost nothing about where it will land.
This does not make the movement wrong. It means that for the brands in this index, origin is a constant, and constants cannot explain differences. The differences must come from somewhere else.
-
What Actually Separates Them
Across all 130 brands, I measured how tightly each of the seven trust dimensions tracks a brand's overall score. Honesty is the tightest, at a correlation of 0.95. Niceness and Respectfulness follow at 0.94, then Friendliness and Tolerance at 0.92. Sustainability (0.69) and Adventurousness (0.66) are well behind. Standing in the GCBI is overwhelmingly built from whether a brand is seen as honest, kind, and respectful in how it treats people, and much less from whether it is novel or green.
Set that beside the Ipsos finding. Fifty-three percent of Canadians say they would walk away from a company that overstates how Canadian its products are. That is not a nationalist preference. It is a Honesty test, applied to the exact claim the movement encourages brands to make. A brand that leans on "Canadian" is inviting the dimension that the data says matters most to be tested against it. If the claim is precise, it earns credit. If it is stretched, it costs more than silence would have.
Our published Travel report shows what the opposite looks like in a category full of nationally branded companies. It finds that "every Canadian airline in the GCBI sits below the national average in 2026 and every airline declined year-over-year," and concludes that "the airline perception problem is structural, not cyclical." Air Canada is the flag carrier, and it sits at #127. A national name and national scale have not protected it, and the report attributes the decline to "flight disruptions, baggage fees, cramped cabins, and service cuts," not to where any airline was founded. The Travel report is free, and if you want to see how a whole category can be nationally branded and still sit at the bottom, it is worth reading.
-
A Patriotic Surge and a Trust Recession at the Same Time
This is the number that I think deserves the most attention. In 2026, 93 of the 130 GCBI brands declined, and the average score fell 0.44 points. The dimensions that fell fastest are the relational ones: Niceness down 0.80 points on average, Tolerance 0.77, Friendliness 0.76, Respectfulness 0.75. Honesty fell 0.54, Sustainability 0.33, and Adventurousness 0.24.
So the same Canadians who, by Abacus's count, are buying more Canadian goods than they were last year also rated Canadian brands lower on almost every measure of trust. I cannot say the movement caused any of this, and it would be a mistake to read the two as cause and effect. But the timing is a useful corrective to a popular assumption, which is that a wave of national solidarity lifts the brands it is meant to help. In the data, it did not lift the field. The field fell.
There is a longer-standing body of research that predicts this gap. Verlegh and Steenkamp's 1999 meta-analysis of country-of-origin studies found that origin shapes perceived quality more strongly than it shapes purchase intentions. Carrington, Neville, and Whitwell's 2010 work on ethical consumers, titled for the question of why they do not walk their talk, found that stated ethical intentions routinely give way to price, convenience, and habit. Abacus's finding that 61% say buying Canadian costs more is the real-world version of that constraint. And moral licensing, described by Merritt, Effron, and Monin in 2010, suggests a quieter risk: once a shopper feels they have done the patriotic thing, they may feel entitled to relax on everything else, including the scrutiny they apply to a brand's actual behaviour.
-
The Field is Separating
One more number. The spread of scores across brands widened this year. The standard deviation of GCBI scores rose from 1.67 to 1.95. The best brands pulled away from the worst, and the shape of the whole distribution became more stretched. Indigo rose 1.18 points, Canadian Tire 1.15, Roots 1.04. Rogers fell 1.05, Intact 1.50, Flair Airlines 1.41.
That is not what a rising tide looks like. It is what happens when some brands earn trust in a hard year and others lose it, with national identity doing little to even things out. Canada Goose is a useful example of how this works in the other direction: it moved from #91 to #57, and Canada Dry from #24 to #13, both brands with Canadian identity at the heart of how they are marketed. But Canada Dry's parent company is, as I understand it, American-owned, which is worth verifying before anyone cites it. The point is that "Canadian" can mean origin, ownership, production, or heritage, and ordinary shoppers do not agree on which one counts.
There is another example in the data that I find telling. No Name, Loblaw's value-priced private label, rose from #48 to #20 this year, a gain of 28 places. Loblaws itself is last at #130 for a second straight year. A shopper's trust attaches to the product they hold in their hand, not to the corporate parent whose name appears on the door. If trust is built at the product level, then a movement that asks people to choose by corporate origin is asking them to use a different signal than the one they use when they actually trust something.
-
Who the Movement Reaches
The GCBI can also show who rates Canadian brands highly, and the pattern is not uniform. On political lines, Conservative supporters give these brands an average of 66.03, Liberal supporters 65.01, and NDP supporters 60.57. The Buy Canadian sentiment itself is broad and crosses party lines, but baseline trust in the brands that benefit from it varies by about 5.5 points between the most and least trusting groups. A movement that treats Canadian brands as a single trusted bloc is speaking to an audience that does not hold that view equally.
Age is more striking. Ipsos found that 70% of baby boomers had bought Canadian because of trade tensions, compared with 52% of Millennials and 46% of Gen Z. In the GCBI, Baby Boomers are the group whose average rating of Canadian brands fell the most, down 1.47 points, while Gen X was the only generation whose ratings rose, up 0.31. These are different surveys, fielded at different times, and I would not push the comparison too far. But if the group most likely to buy Canadian is also the group losing faith in Canadian brands fastest, that is a gap worth watching: motivation to buy and confidence in what is bought are moving in different directions.
-
What Brands Should Take From This
Four implications follow from the data, and none of them requires a political position on the movement. First, be exact about what Canadian means. If a brand claims Canadian origin, say what that covers: where it is made, where it is owned, where the jobs sit. Ipsos found that over half of Canadians would punish exaggeration, and Honesty is the dimension most tightly bound to standing in the GCBI. Imprecision is the cheapest way to turn a flag-waving asset into a liability.
Second, compete on the dimensions that predict standing. Niceness, Respectfulness, and Honesty are what separate the top from the bottom of this index. Ipsos's own pollster made the same point when he said Canadian suppliers gain an advantage only when they are competitive on price and quality. Origin earns a look. It does not earn a second purchase.
Third, take the price gap seriously. When 61% of shoppers say buying Canadian costs more, a brand asking for a premium is asking for trust it needs to have earned in advance. The respectful version of that ask is transparency about why the price is what it is.
Fourth, keep sales and trust on separate dashboards. The Buy Canadian surge can lift revenue while the dimensions that define standing continue to erode. A strong quarter is evidence the movement is working for the brand. It is not evidence that Canadians trust the brand more.
-
What to Watch in 2027
I would rather leave a falsifiable test than an opinion. If Buy Canadian functions as a trust builder, three things should show up in next year's GCBI. The number of brands that decline should fall well below 93. The spread between the top and bottom of the index should narrow instead of widen. And the large, nationally embedded names at the bottom should start to close the gap with those at the top.
If instead the spread keeps widening and the bottom five look much as they do today, then the movement will have shaped where Canadians shop without changing what they think of the brands they shop at. That would be a finding worth having: that being Canadian gets a brand considered, and that everything after that is still earned.
The question I will leave with you: is "Canadian" a reason to buy, or a reason to trust? The data says they are different questions, and that only one of them has an answer that holds up year after year.