Canada’s Coffee Chains are Quietly Losing Their Bet on the Next Generation

  • Author: Eugene Chan
    Published: 8 November 2026 on LinkedIn

    This entry in the Great Canadian Brand Ledger summarizes the 2026 GCBI Coffee & QSR Industry Report, part of an annual series that tracks how Canadians perceive 14 leading coffee and quick-service restaurant brands across seven dimensions of trust, and how those perceptions shifted between the 2025 and 2026 editions of the Great Canadian Brand Index (GCBI).

    Below, I walk through some of this year's most interesting findings and share my own take on what's driving them. The full report — complete rankings for all 14 brands, regional and demographic breakdowns, and year-over-year movement — is free to download, in both English and French (fr-CA) by clicking here.

    A question I get from clients in food service more than almost any other: is coffee still a growth category in Canada, or has it quietly become a mature, defensive one? This year's Great Canadian Brand Index (GCBI) data gives a clearer answer than I expected — and it isn't the same answer for every brand wearing the coffee-and-QSR badge.

    We track 14 brands across this combined category: five coffee chains and nine quick-service restaurants (QSRs). The QSRs break down further: six burger brands, two chicken brands, and one pizza brand. Two subcategories, one combined ranking — and this year, they moved in opposite directions.

  • Two Subcategories, Two Very Different Years

    QSR brands — Harvey's, A&W, Wendy's, McDonald's, Burger King, KFC, Popeyes, Pizza Pizza, and Subway — collectively fell 0.12 points, essentially flat. Coffee chains — Tim Hortons, Starbucks, Second Cup, Country Style, and Tim Hortons (again, because its U.S. operations carry the name) — fell 0.76 points. The category as a whole ranks #2 of 12 industries, at 65.09, so this isn't a story of a struggling category. It's a story of a category with a widening internal gap.

    The rankings make the split concrete. Tim Hortons leads the combined ranking at 68.21, down 0.35. McDonald's is right behind at 67.83, up 0.22. Subway is third at 67.42, up 1.35. But the bottom of the ranking is dominated by coffee chains: Starbucks is 12th at 63.02, down 1.25 — the biggest year-over-year drop in the category. Second Cup is 13th at 60.71, down 0.60. Dairy Queen is last at 58.96, down 0.90.

    The coffee segment is in structural trouble, and it's worth saying plainly. QSR brands have flatlined, but they've held their ground. Coffee chains are moving backwards — and the gap between the two subcategories widened by 0.64 points this year alone.

  • The Generational Signal that Should Worry Coffee Chains Most

    Here's the finding I keep coming back to: Tim Hortons' score among Gen Z is 64.1, down 0.50 points. Among Millennials, it's 66.0, down 1.10 — the largest generational decline in the category. Baby Boomers score the brand 70.7, up 0.19. The generation that will define Tim Hortons' next 20 years is the one rating it lowest, and the only generation rating it higher than last year is the one that matters least to its future.

    My honest, subjective take: the generational drift is partly about price — coffee has gotten expensive, and Gen Z feels it more — and partly about relevance. A brand that is a reliable habit for Boomers risks becoming an expensive one for Gen Z. Tims' strength is Friendliness (63.5) and Respectfulness (65.6); its weakness is Tolerance (66.6) and Adventurousness (59.4). The pattern is consistent: the brand is warm and polite, but it reads as cautious and closed.

  • The Brands Quietly Doing Something Unusual

    Two names in the QSR side of the category stand out for me. Subway rose 1.35 points to 67.42, the largest gain in the category, driven by a 2.1-point jump in Friendliness — the largest single-dimension gain of any brand in the category this year. And A&W rose 0.62 points to 67.38, with its strongest gains in Honesty and Respectfulness. Neither brand has reinvented itself. Both have been quietly consistent in how they show up.

    Whether that position is replicable — or just hard to defend — is the question. My honest take is that Subway and A&W have been disciplined in a way the coffee chains haven't been. QSRs have stuck to their core value propositions while coffee chains have drifted into price-led positioning. The data can't prove that theory, but it's the most coherent reading of why the QSR side has held while coffee has slipped.

  • A Political Undercurrent Worth Naming

    One brand in this category shows a notable political split, and I want to name it without overclaiming. Dairy Queen scores 60.2 among Conservative supporters and 57.1 among NDP supporters, a 3.1-point gap that is the largest political spread of any brand in the category — and well above the category's 2.2-point median. Whether that reflects a genuine political signal or something specific to the brand is a question I leave open, but I flag it because it's unusually large for a category where politics is usually a minor factor.

  • What I'd Flag If I Were Advising Anyone in this Category

    • If you're a coffee chain: Gen Z is your canary. The brand that is losing its youngest customers fastest is also the one with the most to lose. Any strategy that doesn't start with why Gen Z rates you 4.5 points lower than Boomers is a strategy that isn't looking at the problem.

    • If you're a QSR: the opportunity is real, but so is the ceiling. You've held your ground while coffee has slipped, and that's a genuine advantage. But the category's flat year should make you wary of assuming that hold is permanent — especially if coffee chains figure out how to win back their younger customers.

    • If you're tracking the broader market: coffee and QSR are a category where the headline — #2 of 12 industries — hides the split. The lesson generalizes: a category ranking tells you where the category stands, but not which brands are doing the standing.

  • Why the Split Matters Beyond This Category

    What I find genuinely interesting is what this split tells us about categories that look healthy from the outside. The Coffee & QSR category ranks #2 of 12 industries, and on that evidence alone you'd think it was one of the most trusted places in Canadian branding. Look one level deeper, and the coffee side is losing ground while the QSR side is holding. A category can be strong and fragile at the same time, and the fragility is usually in the subcategory you stopped watching.

    The full 2026 GCBI Coffee & QSR Industry Report includes complete rankings for all 14 brands, year-over-year movers, dimension-by-dimension profiles, regional breakdowns across all six Canadian regions, and generational, gender, income, and political demographic cuts — including which brands are named above. It's free to download, available in both English and French (fr-CA). Download the full report here: https://brandindex.ca/2026report-coffeeqsr