Rogers Wants Canadians to Treat a 1.6% Credit Card Fee as Routine. The Trust Data Says It Isn't Starting From Routine.
-
Author: Eugene Chan
Published: 15 November 2026 on LinkedInThe Great Canadian Brand Ledger is built on the Great Canadian Brand Index (GCBI), a nationally representative survey of Canadian adults (3,441 respondents in 2026, weighted to 2021 Census benchmarks across age, gender, race, and political affiliation) that measures how Canadians perceive over 130 major brands across seven behavioural trust dimensions: Friendliness, Niceness, Respectfulness, Honesty, Tolerance, Adventurousness, and Sustainability. Brand-level scores are generated using Bayesian shrinkage estimation for stability and reliability, producing each brand's overall GCBI score alongside its individual dimension scores. Where the GCBI provides the annual scores and rankings, the Ledger interprets what's actually moving underneath them, turning value-level shifts into insight about institutional trust, alignment, and drift.
Starting January 17, 2027, Rogers will charge a 1.6% processing fee on bills paid by credit card. Rogers says the fee "reflects the fees we are charged by credit card companies," that its processing costs have risen nearly 40% since 2020 to about $150 million a year, and that such charges are "increasingly common across many sectors." Debit, direct debit, and online banking payments are exempt, and so is Quebec, where provincial consumer protection law prohibits this kind of fee. The reported coverage also says the fee applies to payments made with the Rogers Bank Mastercard.
I want to look at this from a different angle than the fee itself. The question I can answer with the Great Canadian Brand Index (GCBI) is not whether 1.6% is reasonable, but how much trust Rogers has to spend when it asks Canadians to accept it. A company's explanation for a fee is only as persuasive as the company's standing with the people hearing it, and on that, the data is unusually clear.
Some limitations first. The 2026 GCBI was collected before this announcement, so it shows the starting position, not the reaction. I cannot measure how Canadians feel about the fee itself, and the 2027 survey will be the first chance to see it. Coverage is also inconsistent about whether Fido and former Shaw customers are affected, so I stay with Rogers throughout. Finally, the numbers Rogers has put forward and the numbers critics have pointed to measure different things, and I flag where that matters.
-
The Position Rogers is Starting From
Rogers Communications ranks #129 of 130 brands in the 2026 GCBI, with a score of 58.39. Bell is #128 at 58.43 and TELUS is #123 at 61.18. The three national carriers sit in the bottom eight of the index. On the individual dimensions, Rogers is last of all 130 brands on Friendliness, #129 on both Niceness and Respectfulness, and #128 on Honesty. It was already #128 overall last year, and its composite fell another 1.05 points this year, faster than Bell (down 0.78) and Telus (down 0.28).
The category matters too. Telecom sits in what the GCBI calls the Service industry, which averages 62.53 and ranks eleventh of twelve industries. Our published Financial Services report notes that financial services is last, at 62.49, "trailing the next-lowest industry (Service, 62.53) by a narrow margin." So the two industries Canadians most associate with fees, bills, and fine print are the two Canadians trust least. Rogers is asking for the benefit of the doubt inside the least-trusted neighbourhood of the index, from the least-trusted address in it.
One more number matters. Rogers' distrust is not concentrated in one group. It ranks #130 in Ontario and #129 in Quebec, the province where the fee will not apply. It ranks #129 in the Prairies and Atlantic Canada, #127 in British Columbia, and #125 in Alberta, its best region. It ranks #130 among Conservative supporters, #129 among NDP supporters, and #128 among Liberal supporters. In the Air Canada entry I described a brand whose score depends heavily on who is asked. Rogers is the opposite case. Nearly every group lands in the same place.
-
The Fairness Test the Fee Has to Pass
The behavioural science on how people judge a price increase is older than most people expect. In their 1986 paper on fairness as a constraint on profit seeking, Kahneman, Knetsch, and Thaler found that people accept a price increase that passes on a genuine cost increase, because the firm is protecting a reference level of profit. They reject increases that exploit a customer's situation, because the firm is taking more than it was entitled to. Rogers' explanation is a textbook cost pass-through argument: our costs rose, so we are passing them on.
That argument works when the audience believes the firm. It weakens when other facts compete with it. Rogers' third-quarter free cash flow was reported at $1.37 billion, up about 65% from a year earlier, though that is a company-defined measure for one quarter and the $150 million in processing costs is an annual figure, so they are not directly comparable. The comparison is not an accounting one. It is the one a customer makes without a spreadsheet: a company reporting strong cash generation is asking for more money.
There is a second complication. Global News reports that the CFO described a March CRTC ban on fees to cancel or change plans as having the "largest impact" on the company, and that Rogers is looking for "alternatives" to cover those lost revenues. The coverage does not say the card fee is that alternative, and I am not claiming it is. But customers may connect the two, and when a firm gives two reasons for one fee, the more convenient one starts to look like cover for the other.
-
Why Trust Changes How the Same Fee is Read
The explanation for this comes from attribution theory, which goes back to Heider and Kelley. When a company does something that costs us money, we ask whether the cause lies in the situation, such as rising costs, or in the company's character, such as a wish to extract more. A brand with trust in reserve gets the situational reading. A brand without it gets the dispositional one.
The GCBI measures exactly the dimensions that tilt that judgment. Across all 130 brands, Honesty, Niceness, and Respectfulness are the three dimensions most tightly bound to a brand's overall standing, at correlations of 0.95, 0.94, and 0.94. Rogers ranks #128, #129, and #129 on them. Put simply, the dimensions that help customers read a fee charitably are the ones where Rogers is weakest.
Rogers also leans on a social-proof argument, that these charges are "increasingly common." Descriptive norms do influence what people accept, as Cialdini's work shows. But the claim is about "many sectors," not telecoms, and the closest precedent in the category cuts the other way. Telus proposed a similar 1.5% fee in 2022 and withdrew it about a year later after customer complaints. Bell, as reported, has not introduced one. A norm that the nearest competitors have not adopted is a weak norm.
-
The Framing Problem
There is a well-known way this kind of change is received differently depending on how it is labelled. Thaler's 1980 work on consumer choice, building on Kahneman and Tversky's prospect theory, described the difference between a credit card surcharge and a cash discount. Economically they can be identical. Psychologically they are not, because a surcharge is felt as a loss and a discount is a gain forgone. Thaler recounts that the credit card industry itself pushed to have the difference labelled a discount for exactly this reason.
Rogers has chosen the surcharge framing, the version customers feel as a loss. There is also a rewards offset to consider. Many customers pay by credit card precisely because of cash back or points, and cash-back cards commonly return somewhere between 1% and 2%, close to the fee itself. For those customers, the fee does not feel like a small charge. It feels like losing the benefit they chose the card for.
And then there is a detail that I suspect will travel. The reported coverage says the fee also applies to the Rogers Bank Mastercard. A customer who holds Rogers' own bank card, and pays their Rogers bill with it, will pay Rogers 1.6% to use Rogers' product. That is the kind of detail that gets screenshotted.
-
Why a Small Number Can Feel Large
A fee of 1.6% on a $100 bill is $1.60, which on its face is trivial. Fees like this rarely land as their arithmetic. A phone bill is among the most repeated payments in a household's year, so the charge is not felt once but twelve times, and it re-appears each month on a statement the customer is already inclined to scrutinize. Prelec and Loewenstein's 1998 work on the pain of paying suggests that people who choose credit cards partly to soften the sense of paying are the ones who notice the charge most when it re-couples cost to payment.
The people who feel it first are also the ones the data says rate Rogers lowest. Millennials score the brand 57.2 and rank it #128, and Gen Z gives it 59.4 and ranks it #129. Baby Boomers score it 62.7. The younger groups are the heaviest users of app-based and card-based payment, and the ones for whom a $1.60 charge competes with a long list of other small irritations. This is the same pattern the Travel report calls "a persistent experience-expectation gap" for airlines: the generation that uses a service most is often the one most ready to notice when it gets worse.
-
The Masthead is the Problem, Not the Family
One more piece of GCBI evidence deserves attention. Rogers' flanker brand Fido ranks #102 at 62.88, 4.5 points above the Rogers name. Telus's Koodo ranks #77 at 63.66, 2.5 points above Telus. In both cases the discount brand carries more trust than the corporate parent. I saw a similar pattern with No Name and Loblaws in the Buy Canadian entry: trust attaches to the thing the customer interacts with, not always to the name on the building. For Rogers, that raises a strategic question. If the Rogers masthead is the one carrying the distrust, introducing a fee through that masthead concentrates the damage there.
-
What a Better Version Looks Like
Four moves follow from the data, none of which requires Rogers to abandon the fee. First, be exact about what the fee recovers. Honesty is where Rogers ranks #128, and it is the dimension most tightly bound to standing. Rogers should publish how 1.6% relates to the costs it actually pays, and say plainly if the fee covers more than that. A claim that costs were passed through is credible only if it can be checked.
Second, change the frame. A discount for debit or direct debit achieves much of the same cost shift while landing as a forgone gain, not a loss. If the economics require a surcharge, the second best option is to offset it, for example with a bill credit for customers who stay on credit with auto-pay.
Third, protect the customers the brand cannot afford to lose. Rogers Bank Mastercard holders are the clearest case, and they should be exempted or compensated. Rewards-driven customers are another. A company with Rogers' trust position can ill afford to turn its most engaged customers into its loudest critics.
Fourth, use the weeks before January 17 to communicate, not to wait. The Financial Services report, which is free, makes a point worth quoting in this context. It notes that CIBC rose from #115 to #92 nationally this year and now leads financial services on Honesty, and it concludes that "owning the Honesty dimension in a sector perpetually under public scrutiny is a distinctive positioning that, if sustained, could compound into a durable competitive advantage." Banks charge fees constantly, and they are one of the least trusted industries in the index. CIBC, which posted that category's second-largest gain, now leads it on Honesty. The same door is open to a telecom, and Rogers is the one standing furthest from it.
-
What to Watch For in 2027
Because Quebec is exempt, the data will give us something rare: a natural comparison. If the fee hurts trust, then Rogers' scores outside Quebec should fall faster than in Quebec in the 2027 GCBI, assuming the survey is fielded after the fee takes effect. If Rogers' decline is the same everywhere, the fee is not the driver, and the problem is deeper than one charge. I would also watch whether Bell follows, since that would test the claim that this is "increasingly common," and whether Rogers reverses course as Telus did. And I would watch Honesty and Friendliness against Bell and Telus. Rogers is already last on one and #128 on the other.
The question I will leave you with: when a brand that Canadians already rank near the bottom asks them to accept a new fee as routine, are they being asked to understand a cost, or to extend trust that the brand has not yet earned? The data suggests that Rogers is asking for the second while explaining the first.